Home > Knowledge > Content

2 ways to measure oil viscosity

May 20, 2020

The two methods of measuring and reporting viscosity, kinematic and absolute (also called dynamic), often cause confusion in the minds of those who do not use them regularly. In this column, I'll explain the differences between them and provide some tips on how to apply them to lubricants.

absolute viscosity
Absolute viscosity is defined as a fluid's resistance to shear, or the fluid's ability to resist deformation when a force is applied. Put more simply, the thicker the fluid, the more energy it takes to make it flow. Strictly speaking, kinematic viscosity is defined as the ratio of absolute viscosity to density.

Density is a property derived from mass, and since mass and weight are for practical purposes directly proportional anywhere on the Earth's surface, kinematic viscosity is often interpreted as the resistance of a fluid to flow under the influence of gravity.

I like to think of kinematic viscosity as a special case of absolute viscosity. The shear forces introduced by gravity are actually very small compared to the shear forces introduced by the mechanical interaction of machine components.

Let's illustrate this difference with an example. Suppose you have a jar of honey and a jar of water on your desk. The jars are fixed to the table so they cannot move. If you put a spoon in each jar and start stirring, you are introducing shear into the fluid.

Note that these forces are not caused by gravity, so what you are doing is an absolute viscosity test. Obviously, the fluid with greater resistance to stirring is honey, so we can conclude that the absolute viscosity of honey is greater than the absolute viscosity of water. Now take those jars, take them off the table, and pour them aside.

The fluid will all flow out of the tank, in this case the force causing the flow is introduced by gravity. So we just did a kinematic viscosity test and that also showed that honey has a greater kinematic viscosity than water because it has more resistance to flow out of the jar.

The viscosity of a fluid, whether kinematic or absolute, changes depending on the measured temperature. Therefore, the temperature at which the viscosity is measured must be reported.

kinematic viscosity
As a strict definition of the state of motion, if the density of the fluid is known, absolute viscosity and kinematic viscosity can be converted directly. This relationship can be expressed as:

Absolute viscosity = kinematic viscosity x density

Appropriate SI units must be used to use this formula correctly.

So far we have shown that both absolute and kinematic viscosity tests prove that honey is more viscous than water. Let's look at another example.

Using two identical jars fixed to the table, fill one with honey and the other with mayonnaise. Now perform an absolute viscosity test by stirring the fluid. Testing will show that honey is a more viscous liquid.

Turn the jar over and do a kinematic viscosity test, which will show that the mayonnaise is now a more viscous liquid (honey will run out faster than mayonnaise). First what is the explanation for the different results and second what are the implications, at least as far as machine lubricants are concerned?

difference
In order to explain the different results, we need to understand the Newtonian properties of the fluid. If you relate the viscosity of a fluid to the amount of shear it experiences, some fluids exhibit a viscosity that is independent of the amount of shear force applied.

These are called Newtonian fluids, of which honey is a good example. The viscosity distribution of some fluids changes with the amount of shear experienced. These are called non-Newtonian fluids, mayonnaise being an example.

Non-Newtonian fluids exhibit high viscosities when the shear rate is low (kinematic viscosity test). As with the absolute viscosity test, the viscosity of non-Newtonian fluids decreases when the fluid is sheared more strongly.

why it's important
So what does this mean for lubricants?

1. Most lubricants (see exceptions below) exhibit near-Newtonian properties. So whether we measure kinematic viscosity or absolute viscosity and trend it, there is not much difference.

2. Oils that exhibit more non-Newtonian properties are:

Improved lubricants (oils with viscosity index improving additives)

Degraded oil

Oil emulsions, including moderate contamination of solids and/or liquids and air entrainment, all of which can produce emulsions.

3. Given that mechanically introduced shear forces, rather than gravity, affect the flow of lubricating fluid in a machine, it can be argued that absolute viscosity testing is a better method of determining viscosity. However, it is also fair to assume that any factor that affects changes in absolute viscosity may also affect changes in kinematic viscosity.

As long as we measure and trend one measurement method (with appropriate reproducibility) we should be able to get good patterns in the data. Even though we are making kinematic viscosity measurements and we intuitively know they are incorrect as far as the machine is concerned, they are still popular. So stick to one method. As a joke: It's better to be wrong all the time than right sometimes.

4. Kinematic viscosity is the common method of measuring and reporting viscosity in used lubricant analysis, at least as far as most commercial laboratories are concerned. As mentioned in the previous paragraph, it may not be the best approach, but it has become the dominant approach due to history and ease of use.

5. Most commercial laboratories will use an automated viscometer to measure kinematic viscosity. Most field laboratory instruments will measure absolute viscosity but report it as kinematic viscosity by using fluid density assumptions and performing appropriate calculations.

This is usually not a problem in obtaining trend results, but it is important to ensure that viscosity measurements are always performed at the same temperature. This can be room temperature, but always make sure the oil has had time to reach room temperature in a climate-controlled environment before testing.

And don't try to compare your commercial petroleum lab results to your field lab results too closely; they will be different, but that's because they measure different things. There should be some correlation, but they won't be exactly equivalent.

Viscosity is often considered the most important property of a lubricant. Therefore, it is also important to be able to measure and understand it. I hope this provides a clearer understanding of the subject.

Send Inquiry
Categories